2022: A Year of Theological Thinking
The past year showed us how much religion - especially progressive Christian commentary - matters
Before 2023 dawns, today’s offering looks back to the best posts of the year at The Cottage. It was a big year for religion in the news — reflected in the most widely read and shared of these essays. If your favorite isn’t on the list, please remind us of your most treasured post or offering in the comment thread. You can also revisit the entire year at The Cottage Archive.
At the very bottom of this Year-in-Review post, there are two surprises: one is news of a happy Christmas surprise; the other is a previously paid-only interview has now been opened for everyone at the Cottage.
THE BEST OF THE YEAR: Mary Magdalene
More than 400,000 readers listened to or read my sermon on Mary Magdalene featuring the research of Elizabeth Schrader. Cottage readers made this sermon go globally viral. I’m not kidding — global — it made news in Great Britain, Australia, New Zealand, and Germany. It was, as far as anyone can tell, the most listened to progressive Christian sermon since Bp. Michael Curry’s sermon at the wedding of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle.
TOP THREE POSTS IN NEWS & CULTURE
#1: Religion and the War in Ukraine
This explainer-post attracted national media attention and was widely shared by you, many professional journalists, and several news outlets.
#2 and #3: Christian Nationalism
One post on threat of a civil war and the other on evangelical views of history — generated lively discussion in threads and brought many new readers to The Cottage.
TOP TWO POSTS IN SUNDAY MUSINGS
#1 in Sunday Musings: “Radical Hospitality”
A thematic post on immigrants and the practice of hospitality toward strangers in the Bible followed the news story of people being shipped to Martha’s Vineyard by Florida’s governor.
#2 in Sunday Musings: “The Demons of Empire”
The second most read post in Sunday Musings was on pigs, empire, and Jesus as a political satirist.
TOP POST IN CHRISTIAN THEOLOGY
Occasionally, I write a mid-week piece specifically on a topic in Christian theology. “The Holy Thursday Revolution” was the fifth most-read post at The Cottage in 2022. Many readers wrote me to let me know that it meant a great deal to them personally, that it shifted their own perspective on Holy Week, or that they’d shared it with their congregations.
TOP SAD POST WITH A SURPRISE HAPPY ENDING
When my beloved dog, Rowan, started his journey toward the end of his life last September, I wrote this piece about pets and grief. He died on December 2, an event that gave a bittersweet cast to my Advent reflections.
Then, a happy surprise came on Christmas morning. A Glen in Rowan’s family line had a litter of eight puppies on December 22. We got a text from her wonderful breeder informing us that one of the little guys — a cousin to our own cherished Rowan — will be joining our family in about 10-12 weeks! There was much joy around the Bass family Christmas tree. 🎄 It felt a little like our own “Miracle on 34th Street.”
THANK YOU FOR READING, JOINING, SHARING, COMMENTING ON, AND SUPPORTING THE COTTAGE IN 2022.
It has been a wonderful year of making community, of sharing smart takes and thoughtful theology meant to inspire faith, hope, and love.
I look forward to 2023 as we continue growing and nurturing this place together. In the coming months, I’ll have news of a new book project and other good things, too.
I’m so grateful for your companionship here. Please know that your financial support has made all of this good work possible for everyone who subscribers (free, paid, and gratis) — and has made it available to a large reading public beyond the subscription list. The Cottage is now the third most-read religion publication on Substack.
You all helped make this happen.
AND IF YOU MADE IT ALL THE WAY TO THE END OF THIS POST, A SPECIAL TREAT:
I opened up this paid subscriber post of an interview with Bill McKibben for the entire community. We talked about the book he released this year — The Flag, the Cross, and the Station Wagon — which was one of my favorite reads of 2022. I really enjoyed this conversation.
Hope you’ve enjoyed this 2022 Cottage Year in Review! Please share with a friend.
I’m a recent subscriber so, thank you for posting your highlights! I am sitting in awe right now. As a progressive, out of a conservative Calvinist upbringing, your WG sermon has blown my mind and given me all the best feels!!! What amazing work Libbie did! What a gift in it being shared!
Everyone has a story and there are times when a story must be shared, not just for clarity or for the sake of truth, but also to take back one’s life. My name is Kate Gould. I am a 48 year old mother of two boys ages 7 and 10. My story takes place in a southern suburb of Denver Colorado in 2021 and 2022. I was in my last year of graduate school at the Iliff School of Theology. My boys were in first and fourth grades at our neighborhood elementary school in the Douglas County School District (DCSD). My oldest, Jackson, had been there since kindergarten and loved it. He was a good student, kind, and considerate. My boys walked to school together every day picking up friends in the neighborhood along the way. They were active in gymnastics and music lessons. We were living the suburban version of the “American Dream.” We were happy.
In November of 2021, four new individuals were elected to the Douglas County Board of Education, having run on the platform of “Kids First.” Their platform came straight from the right wing conservative playbook - Critical Race Theory, Anti-Equity, Anti-Mask. Those four individuals represented the new majority and on December 8, 2021, less than one month after they were elected, they removed the mask mandate in Douglas County Public Schools. Those of us with children with medical conditions were told to work with our individual principals to get masking accommodations.
Jackson was diagnosed with cystic fibrosis at three weeks old via newborn screen. He takes over 30 pills and does almost 2 hours of treatments daily, just to stay healthy. Cystic fibrosis is a progressive, life limiting, genetic disease that affects the lungs, pancreas, and other organs. In people with CF, mutations in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene cause the CFTR protein to become dysfunctional. When the protein is not working correctly, it’s unable to help move chloride — a component of salt — to the cell surface. Without the chloride to attract water to the cell surface, the mucus in various organs becomes thick and sticky. In the lungs, the mucus clogs the airways and traps germs, like bacteria, leading to infections, inflammation, respiratory failure, and other complications. For this reason, avoiding germs is a top concern for people with CF.
The morning of December 9, 2021 I went directly to Jackson’s school, Heritage Elementary, and asked to see the principal, Jean Wolach, as parents had been instructed to do by the Board of Education President, Mike Peterson. I was told she was too busy to see me. I told the secretary I would wait. Two hours later, Mrs. Wolach met with me and I asked for a masking accommodation to be placed in Jackson’s 504 medical plan. It was denied. I provided a letter from Jackson’s pulmonologist and it was again denied. I hired a special education attorney. For the next month, the special education attorney and I met with school administrators and continued to be denied. We provided another letter from Jackson’s pulmonologist stating that it was required for Jackson’s lung health that he be in a universally masked classroom. Finally, on January 4, 2022, with the omicron wave in full force across the country, the school district granted Jackson a masking accommodation in his 504. It had been a fight, but I thought we were safe.
In February 2022, the four majority board members fired Corey Wise, the superintendent of DCSD, without cause. Mr. Wise’s attorney maintains Mr. Wise was fired out of retaliation for upholding ADA law as well as the district’s equity policy. Almost immediately, the school administrators began emailing each other about removing my son’s masking accommodation. I learned this through a Colorado Opens Records request in which I obtained all the emails between the principal of my son’s school, the “acting” superintendent, Danelle Hiatt, and the deputy counsel for DCSD, Wendy Jacobs. Despite the emails back and forth from February 18, 2022 to March 1, 2022, at no point was I contacted by anyone from the district or the school concerning Jackson’s masking accommodation. On March 1, 2022 I, along with all the other fourth grade parents, received an email from Jean Wolach stating masking was no longer required in the fourth grade classroom. Without consulting me, Jackson’s father, or Jackson’s physician, the school removed Jackson’s masking accommodation from his 504 placing his health and safety in danger.
I tried to move the boys to a neighboring school district. I was told there was no room. I applied to two private schools and, again, was told there was no room. How does a parent choose between their child’s health and their education? DCSD offered us no alternatives. All of a sudden our “American Dream” had become a nightmare. The school we had been a part of for five years stood by silently while the Board of Education and the acting superintendent endangered Jackson’s health. For five years they had partnered with me to keep Jackson healthy so he could have as normal a childhood as possible. For five years they watched us navigate quarterly doctor’s appointments, illnesses, countless courses of antibiotics, treatment regimens, hospitalization, sinus surgery…and not one of them stood up for Jackson. To say we felt betrayed doesn’t do it justice. They knew what we went through on a daily basis to keep Jackson healthy and when we needed them the most, they were silent.
When Jackson was diagnosed I made a promise to him that I would be his rock. I promised him I would make sure he had the most intentional and meaningful life possible. I promised him I would keep him as healthy as possible in order to have as normal a life as possible for as long as he would get to have it. I was keeping my promise. We were succeeding until four individuals driven by misinformation and a right wing conservative culture war took over the majority on the DCSD Board of Education.
I felt like I had no choice but to pull the boys from the only school they had known. Jackson’s health is our number one priority because keeping him healthy is the key to him having a life to live. After some research and with the assistance of my sister who was already living there, we made the decision to move to California, to a school district that was still masking and willing to accommodate his need for masking if necessary. We left the state in which the boys were born, the neighborhood we lived in for six years, the school they attended for five years, our home, our friends, the pulmonologist who had been caring for Jackson since his diagnosis…we left our entire lives and started over in California. It’s been a difficult transition for all of us. The boys miss their friends and their home. We don’t have the income to support the same kind of life here due to the increased cost of living, but it didn’t feel like we had any other choice. In addition to Jackson’s need for masking and my complete distrust of the school and the district, there were also threats to our safety coming from other parents and eventually, from the Board of Education itself. When I spoke out at a Board of Education meeting I had to be escorted to my car by a county sheriff for my own safety because individuals were giving me the finger and making public comments about my son. One parent sent an email to the principal of Jackson’s school describing what kind of mask he thought Jackson wore, when my son lifted his mask from his face, when he took his mask off to eat lunch, who he played with on the playground and whether or not they were wearing masks, an entire email detailing information about my son and his activities throughout the school day and, of course, the school did nothing, the principal did nothing. One parent sent me a message on social media stating he was going to find my son and make him cry and drink his tears. Recently, Director Becky Myers of the Board of Education sent me an email in which she called me a leftist activist and informed me she is a conservative Christian who will fight to the end for this country and threatened that I am going to lose my rights and that my voice will no longer be heard. The threats got to a point our physician sent me an email asking me to stop appearing publicly for fear over my and Jackson’s safety. Can you imagine? Can you imagine this world we are living in where a 10 year old boy with a chronic, progressive, life limiting illness becomes a target of such hatred? And not only do the school and the district do nothing to protect him, they actually participate? And no one is held accountable. The injustice of the entire situation keeps me up night after night.
Welcome to Red America. NatCon, extremist, right wing, GOP, no matter what you call it, it has real life consequences. What we have been through is just one illustration of the impact of Red America. It has happened to countless others. It has even happened to other families in DCSD. A high school student in DCSD with cystic fibrosis was denied a masking accommodation outright being told it would impact too many people. A student with cancer and undergoing chemotherapy who opted to just do online school because they wanted to remain private. There are currently six open investigations by the US Dept of Education Office of Civil Rights for alleged violations of Free and Appropriate Access to Education (FAPE) in the Douglas Country School District. One of those investigations is ours.
I will continue to tell our story and I will continue to fight for the community we left behind because it is my moral responsibility to do so.